Why You Need to Hire for Attitude

Home » Assessment » Why You Need to Hire for Attitude

We are a certified Continuing Education provider for

HRCI Logo
SHRM Logo
Two people talking over a desk and computer

Why You Need to Hire for Attitude

The people with the worst attitudes can easily talk their way past many interviewers, get the job, keep the extent of their negativity hidden and remain employed too long. This is because those interviewers don’t realize what it takes to uncover the attitude. In fact, it is a rare manger who can detect it. This is because the way to detect attitude is very different from finding out about qualifications.

What are Attitudes?

The person with the worst attitude is a wolf and the person with the best attitude is a good-natured person. The most basic description of attitude has to do with a willingness to support the boss and the team. The willing have good attitudes; the unwilling are wolves. Or, the good attitude types have the long-term benefits of the company at heart, and the wolves have their personal short-term greed as their goal. The unselfish and the selfish.

Have you ever tried to get another employee to do something for you when it was part of her job (yes, in her job description)? Some did it willingly (good attitude) and some would conveniently forget or even protest doing it (bad attitude). We all know what it feels like to run into the unwillingness wall.

We understand this is not a pleasant subject for many people. We like to think of everyone as good. The reality is that some really don’t care what they put us through. In spite of their meanness, we personally feel they should be forgiven and helped—but not hired.

Attitude is completely different from personality traits, skills and ability. For example, a salesperson may have the right personality, skill and ability to sell like gangbusters, but at the same time be a pathological liar (attitude problem). Some may think they still want her to sell until they find out she lies about forecasts, lies to customers about delivery dates, lies to production about what the customer needs and so on. Attitude can sink the ship and often does.

The best way for us to describe attitudes is by starting with the worst cases—the wolves.

Who are These Stinkers?

The wolf has many names:

  • Bad Apple
  • Problem Generator
  • Predators (a psychologist’s name for them)
  • Bully
  • Troublemaker
  • Furry Animal

We like the term “problem generators” because they seem to cause unsolvable problems. For example, the boss pleads, “Could you work overtime tonight to help get this customer’s product delivered on time?” “No,” says the problem generator as he walks away pretending to be deaf. They sure keep employers worried, frustrated and awake at night.

Here are some of the examples we associate with problem generators:

  • A supervisor who did the bare minimum and lied to cover her you know what when deliveries didn’t make it on time.
  • A guy who sexually harassed a coworker even after warnings.
  • A woodworker who would get so upset he threw tools around the shop.
  • A saleswoman who took so many short cuts in explaining things to customers and writing down requirements that most of her orders ran at a loss.
  • A customer service lady who would pester her boss for more pay increases and would let the phone ring too many times before picking up.
  • A union leader who stirred up so much trouble that management finally ended up paying him $25,000.00 to quit.
  • You have probably seen many of the same things yourself and get the picture. To complete the list would take a thick book.
  • The best example for you of a wolf will be the person who caused you the most problems in your life (not an ex or parent). It will be a person you disconnected from and by doing so caused the most relief.

Here is a List of Common Wolf Traits:

  • Creates unsolvable problems
  • Focuses on, “What’s in it for me?”
  • Sees more negative than positive
  • Is defensive
  • Blames others
  • Gets into conflicts with others
  • Tries to make others feel guilty
  • Uses anger or shades of it inappropriately
  • Refuses to change

One of the unique aspects about wolves is their competence. Look at some of the famous ones in history like Hitler, Stalin and Osama Bin Laden. They were competent in many ways. Then there are con artists who are clever enough to fool people. Sometimes they are hired and kept on board because they are so good at their job, despite their obnoxious behavior. It is also that ability to think on their feet that enables them to get jobs and fly under the radar long enough to make firing difficult.

Many clients have asked us how their wolves would affect their businesses, and no matter what we knew, we were never able to predict the damage they caused. All we knew was the result wasn’t going to be pleasant.

Book An Appointment

Schedule a Free Consultation to Turn your Hiring Process into a Top Talent Generating Machine

Talk With Us Now

Identify Top Candidates ASAP

(833) 332-8378

The 7 Stages of Hiring

Filter through The 7 Stages

  • Show me

  • under