How to Test Integrity in Interviews: Employer Guide

·  5 minutes read

Content

    Let’s face it—almost anyone can prep for an interview. They Google common questions, rehearse polished answers, and show up with their best foot forward. But what happens when the candidate who seemed perfect starts shifting blame, ignoring rules, or hiding mistakes once hired?

    That’s the real hiring risk: not a lack of skills—but a lack of integrity.

    So how do you uncover a candidate’s true character during an interview? How do you go beyond surface answers and find someone who’s genuinely honest, accountable, and team-oriented?

    In this guide, we’ll walk you through exactly how to test integrity in interviews, including real-world interview questions to test integrity, red flags to watch for, and tools you can combine with your process to make stronger, safer hiring decisions.

    Why Testing Integrity in Interviews Matters

    Hiring team discussing candidate’s integrity test and interview performance

    You can train for skills. You can’t train someone to take ownership, tell the truth, or respect workplace rules.

    Testing integrity helps you:

    • Avoid toxic hires who blame others, lie, or cut corners
    • Build a trustworthy and accountable culture
    • Reduce risks related to theft, absenteeism, and team conflict
    • Save time, money, and morale by hiring the right people the first time

    What Does Integrity Look Like in an Interview?

    Integrity can be hard to spot—especially if you don’t know what to look for.

    Here are some positive indicators:

    • Willingness to admit past mistakes
    • Emphasis on doing the right thing, even when it’s hard
    • Taking ownership instead of blaming others
    • Showing consistency between values and actions

    And here are red flags:

    • Avoiding questions about accountability
    • Shifting blame to coworkers or managers
    • Vague or evasive responses about past challenges
    • Talking about “bending the rules” as a strength

    The 3 Types of Integrity Questions to Ask in Interviews

    Hiring manager evaluating a candidate's response during integrity interview

    You don’t need trick questions. You need intentional ones. Here are three powerful question types that reveal how candidates really think.

    1. Behavioral Questions

    These ask about real past experiences. They’re gold for revealing patterns of behavior.

    QuestionWhat It Reveals
    “Tell me about a time you made a mistake at work. What did you do next?”Ownership vs. defensiveness
    “Describe a time when you saw someone break a rule. How did you handle it?”Courage and integrity
    “Have you ever had to admit fault to a customer or client?”Honesty and professionalism

    2. Situational Questions

    These pose hypothetical challenges and gauge reasoning and ethics.

    QuestionWhat It Reveals
    “If a team member asked you to cover for them when they were late, what would you do?”Ethical boundaries
    “A customer gives you too much change and doesn’t notice—what’s your response?”Integrity under pressure

    You’ll find more sample questions like these in Sample Integrity Test Questions Employers Can Use.

    3. Value-Based Questions

    These explore a candidate’s beliefs and decision-making principles.

    QuestionWhat It Reveals
    “Do you believe it’s okay to bend rules to meet a deadline?”Rule-following vs. rationalization
    “What does ‘integrity at work’ mean to you?”Personal ethics and alignment with your company values

    What to Listen For in Their Answers

    Sometimes, it’s not just what someone says—it’s how they say it.

    Here’s a simple cheat sheet to help:

    Green FlagsYellow FlagsRed Flags
    Admits fault and explains what they learnedBlames “the situation” without clear learningBlames others or denies responsibility
    Mentions honesty or accountability unpromptedHesitates or seems rehearsedDodges or deflects integrity-related questions
    Explains decision-making process clearlyGives generic answers with no detailJustifies unethical actions as “necessary”

    For a deeper approach, pair your interviews with personality-based tools, as outlined in Personality-Based Integrity Tests: How They Work. These give you context for how someone is wired to behave—not just how they talk in an interview.

    🔧 Want a Shortcut? Use the Positivity & Integrity Assessment Test

    Recruiter reviewing integrity assessment results during hiring process

    If you want to go beyond verbal answers and actually measure integrity at scale, try using a formal assessment alongside your interviews.

    The Positivity & Integrity Assessment Test does exactly that.

    What It Is:

    A 10-minute, science-based test that evaluates:

    TraitWhat It MeasuresWhy It Matters
    IntegrityHonesty, accountability, rule-followingReduces risk and increases trust
    PositivityOptimism, teamwork, morale contributionBoosts team culture
    ResponsibilityOwnership of actions, problem-solvingPrevents finger-pointing and blame

    It’s fast, reliable, and built for roles where trust and collaboration are non-negotiable—from customer service to leadership positions.

    Send candidates a secure link. They complete the test. You get instant insights to strengthen your interviews and decision-making process.

    👉 Book a demo to try it for free

    Expert Tip: Use Structured Interviews

    To make your process fair and effective:

    • Ask the same core integrity questions to every candidate
    • Score answers using a rubric
    • Combine your notes with the assessment results
    • Discuss responses with your team after the interview

    This helps reduce unconscious bias and ensures you’re making decisions based on behavior—not just charm.

    We talk more about structured assessments in Integrity Assessment Questionnaire for Pre-Employment Screening.

    To help you build a well-rounded integrity screening process, check out:

    • What Is an Overt Integrity Test and How You Can Use It as an Employer

    FAQs: How to Test Integrity in Interviews

    1. Can you really test integrity in an interview?

    Yes—but it takes the right questions, active listening, and context. Combine interviews with assessments for a more complete view.

    2. What are good interview questions to test integrity?

    Questions about past mistakes, dealing with rule-breaking, or ethical dilemmas are excellent. Use behavioral, situational, and value-based formats.

    3. What’s the risk of skipping this step?

    You risk hiring people who are dishonest, unreliable, or disruptive to your team—which can cost you time, money, and morale.

    4. Do integrity tests work better than interviews?

    They work best together. Interviews show how candidates express themselves. Tests show how they’re likely to behave long-term.

    5. How do I know if someone’s faking their answers?

    Look for inconsistencies, vague responses, or over-polished answers. A structured integrity test like the Positivity & Integrity Assessment can help validate what they say.

    Final Thoughts: Integrity Is Easier to Hire Than Repair

    You can’t teach integrity after someone’s hired. But you can spot it before the offer.

    By learning how to test integrity—and using thoughtful interview questions to test integrity—you’ll avoid costly mis-hires and build a team of accountable, trustworthy people.

    Pair interviews with tools like the Positivity & Integrity Assessment Test to make every hire count.

    👉 Book a free demo now and hire with confidence, clarity, and character.

    Content

      Fletcher Wimbush  ·  CEO at Discovered.AI
      Fletcher Wimbush · CEO at Discovered.AI
      Book a Demo of Our Assessments Today!